here's how this is going to work:

- all you have to post is the games you think are the "best" overall. I don't care why, or when, or whatever, just BEST ever.

there will be points given to each position and I will update the game list as people begin to post.

1st place gets 5 points
2nd place gets 4 points
3rd place gets 3 points
4th place gets 2 point
5th place gets 1 point

games on different platforms will count for the same game: example: halo2 on xbox and pc will count for halo2

games that are completely different count as different games: example: final fantasy tactics (on PS) is a completely different game than final fantasy tactics advance (on gameboy advance).

if you double post (aka give 2 different lists) I will accept the first one but I won't be going through it with a fine-toothed-comb, so just don't post twice please

my picks (in order) - super mario 3, final fantasy tactics, CS, starcraft, Onimusha 2

-----------------------------------------
Game Rankings:

Rank 1 - 12

1st - Starcraft (27 points)

2nd - Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (19 points)
2nd - Resident Evil 4 (19 points)
2nd - Super Smash Brothers: Melee (19 points)
5th - Warcraft III (17 points)
6th - Metal Gear Solid II (12 points)
7th - Chrono Trigger (10 points)
7th - Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess (10 points)
7th - Final Fantasy Tactics (original PS version) (10 points)
10th - Tales of Symphonia (9 points)
10th - Half-Life 2 (9 points)
10th - Devil May Cry 3 (9 points)

Rank 13 - 31:
13th - Ragnarok Online (8 points)
13th - Super Metroid (8 points)
15th - Final Fantasy XII (7 points)
15th - Final Fantasy VII (7 points)
17th - Counter Strike (6 points)
17th - .hack//gu (6 points)
19th - Super Mario 3 (5 points)
19th - Shadow Hearts II (5 points)
19th - World of Warcraft (5 points)
19th - Sam and Max Hit the Road (5 points)
19th - Legend of Zelda: A Link To The Past (5 points)
19th - Earthbound (5 points)
19th - Shadow of the Collosus (5 points)
19th - Doom (5 point)
19th - Monster Hunter (5 points)
19th - Persona 3 (5 points)
19th - God of War 2 (5 points)
19th - Lunar: Eternal Blue (5 points)
19th - Suikoden (5 points)

Rank 32 - 42

32nd - Kingdom Hearts II (4 points)
32nd - Jump Ultimate Star (4 points)
32nd - Guardian Heroes (4 points)
32nd - Final Fantasy II (4 points)
32nd - Kirby's Air Ride (4 points)
32nd - Shenmue (4 points)
32nd - Legend of Zelda: Majoras Mask (4 points)
32nd - Impossible Mission (4 points)
32nd - Fatal Frame (4 points)
32nd - Psychonauts (4 points)
32nd - Halo (4 points)

Rank 43 - 57:

43rd - Guilty Gear (3 points)
43rd - Metroid Prime (3 points)
43rd - Soul Calibur III (3 points)
43rd - Lionheart (3 points)
43rd - SSX3 (3 points)
43rd - Super Mario 64 (3 points)
43rd - Dance Dance Revolution (3 points)
43rd - Lineage II (3 points)
43rd - Theif II (3 points)
43rd - Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker (3 points)
43rd - Morrowmind (3 points)
43rd - Command & Conquer 3 (3 points)
43rd - Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (3 points)
43rd - God of War (3 points)
43rd - Warhammer 2k - Dawn of War (3 points)

Rank 58 - 76:

58th - Full Throttle (2 points)
58th - Parasite Eve II (2 points)
58th - Myth The Fallen Lords (2 points)
58th - Doom 2 (2 points)
58th - Pokemon (2 points)
58th - Super Mario World (2 points)
58th - Turrican 2 (2 points)
58th - Pro Evolution Soccer (2 points)
58th - We Love Katamari (2 points)
58th - Need For Speed Carbon (2 points)
58th - Skies of Arcadia Legends (2 points)
58th - Animal Crossing (2 points)
58th - Day of the Tentacle (2 points)
58th - Onimusha 3 (2 points)
58th - Golden Sun (2 points)
58th - Need For Speed: Most Wanted (2 points)
58th - Return to Castle Wolfenstein (2 points)
58th - Fina (2 points)
58th - Megaman X8 (2 points)

77th - Onimusha 2 (1 point)
77th - Power Stone (1 point)
77th - Grand Theft Auto III (1 point)
77th - Devil May Cry (1 point)
77th - Melty Blood (1 point)
77th - Unreal Tournament 2004 (1 point)
77th - Need For Speed Porsche (1 point)
77th - Xenosaga (1 point)
77th - Mercenaries (1 point)
77th - Riven (1 point)
77th - Jet Set Willy (1 point)
77th - No One Lives Forever (1 point)
77th - Final Fantasy VIII (1 point)

hmm... considering there's two of us voting... my vote actually counts!
my votes::

1st - Chrono Trigger (SNES)
2nd - Shenmue (DC)
3rd - Tales of Symphonia (GC)
4th - Full Throttle (PC)
5th - Power Stone 1 (DC)

hah right now we have a 5 different ties... as people begin to post, the points will start to balance out better.

Thanks for posting !

-Boojitsu21

1) Chrono Trigger
2) Psychonauts
3) Super Mario 64
4) Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
5) Grand Theft Auto III

1)Resident Evil 4
2)Final Fantasy XII
3)Guilty Gear
4)Pro Evolution Soccer
5)Devil May Cry
6)Starcraft
7)Melty Blood
8)Gunz Online
9)Naruto Naruttimate Hero 3
10)God Of War 2

Quote by nedved111)Resident Evil 4
2)Final Fantasy XII
3)Guilty Gear
4)Pro Evolution Soccer
5)Devil May Cry
6)Starcraft
7)Melty Blood
8)Gunz Online
9)Naruto Naruttimate Hero 3
10)God Of War 2

you only can vote for your top 5...
so right now I'm going to only use RE4 - Devil May Cry

if you wanna change your list, just message me (I probably won't notice if you edit)

-Boojitsu21

oh...ok sorry

no problem, just letting you know that your bottom 5 wouldn't get any points

-Boojitsu21

1) EarthBound
2) Metal Gear Solid 2
3) Final Fantasy Tactics ( original ps version )
4) Onimusha 3
5) Melty Blood ( theres a buncha versions so just stick with that name )

1 suikoden (series)
2 metal gear (series)
3 fftactics
4 re4
5 fatal frame

1. Starcraft
2. Half-Life 2
3. Morrowind
4. Doom 2
5. Unreal Tournament 2004

1. Devil may cry 3
2. Metal Gear solid 2
3. Sould calibur 3
4. Final fantasy XII
5. Resident evil 4

1. Shadow hearts 2: convenant
2. final fantasy iii
3. lineage 2
4. ragnarok online
5. need for speed: porsche

(lol my submissions are pretty different from the others)

1) Starcraft
2) Warcraft III (including WoW and Frozen Throne)
3) Command And Conquer 3: Tiberium Wars
4) Need for Speed carbon
5) Pokemon series..

Hahaz.. These are just perfect for fun games..

1. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
2. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
3. Stepmania/Dance Dance Revolution series
4. Super Mario World
5. Animal Crossing series

1. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
2. Super Smash Bros. Melee
3. Tales of Symphonia (GC)
4. Golden Sum (GBA)
5. Pokemon RPG series

1) Starcraft
2) Resident Evil 4 (Biohazard)
3) GTA San Andreas
4) Need for Speed Most Wanted
5) Doom (The First)

Just a note that "Morrow Mind" in the official list should be "Morrowind."

Carry on!

thanks, i'll correct it

-Boojitsu21

1: Legend of Zelda: Twillight Princess (Wii)
2: Final Fantasy VII
3: Super Metroid (SNES)
4: Tales of Symphonia
5: Final Fantasy XII

Well, thats it :P

1: Super Metroid (SNES)
2: Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past (SNES)
3: Thief 2: The Metal Age (PC)
4: Myth: The Fallen Lords (PC)
5: Riven [the sequel to Myst] (PC)

ehh... the first I can think of

1) Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
2) Super Smash Brothers: Melee
3) God of War 2 or 1 the series is nice
4) Ragnarok Online
5) Animal Crossing xD

1) Warcraft III
2) Halo
3) Devil May Cry 3
4) Return To Castle Wolfenstein
5) Starcraft

1. Shadow of the Colossus (absolutely incredible. It deserves much more recognition than it gets)
2. Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
3. Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
4. We <3 Katamari
5. Super Smash Bros. Melee

Choosing five games is hard especially when not trying to make the list Zelda dominated. lol.