Hi every body.

I post here my last wall about bleach and MIB. Help me to bring the piece of evidence that's not a poor work ! MOderator say that my star are poor and the quality of the scan too.

But star are like a mib pic... i don't want do better star because, it is not the subject MIB. And the quality scan is not bad in my mind...

what do you think about it ?

http://kayindana.free.fr/wallpapers/bmib.jpg

Your main picture actually looks like it need more character cleaning. The main picture also appear to be less clean and clear then the sharply crisp space BG and the MIB writing, the contrast between the two isn't a good match and ends up making the middle picture look worse.

Neat idea and nice wall.
My suggest would be to tone down the white horizontal lines, improve the character images (or maybe give them that old scratchy TV look). Also add something behind the characters that keeps with the them of the wall. I would also expand teh centered picture torwards the top of the wall. This wall would still look good if the character area was off-center or irregular in shape.

Quote by bromithia
Kaien-dono: You didn't make many changes from the previous version. You should have posted it in the Sandbox and recieved more critisism before posting it again. The scans still have a bad extraction and are low quality. The stars in the background are really low quality, too.

Quote by bluSake@Kaien-dono: As said before, the scans in the galleries are just stock; that it is there does not imply that it is walling quality. Scans usually need to be cleaned before they can be used for walls. The copy of the scan in question that is in the gallery is very grainy, but is the largest and highest quality version of that scan that has been submitted to MT.

I'm just curious to know if you listened to anything the moderators said before you uploaded it again, I see nothing different from this version you have here and the one you uploaded back into the gallery.

Edit: I apologize, I see that the faces look different like the lines that were there were smudged. However I think the background needs some serious work as well as behind the characters it still looks like the stock image.

i think it's way TOO simple...you just used the scan (uncleaned) and not extracted then did a simple bg...

fluke, the scan quality has been work. And in my mind, about the bacjkground, can be with big constallation or big star. Soft background, or soft, all, don't want to say that was a poor work.

I actually like the millions of little stars in the background. I think there is definately some work to be done with the scan quality, that is the risk when you put anime on "real life" backgrounds. It needs to be crisp and clean to fit with the background. I think it looks promising sofar and I look forward to seeing it when it is done ^_^*

Like I said before, I like your wallpaper... I like the logo that you've made, and the idea is really cool. But from what I've seen, Minitokyo mods have a rather harsh policy and sometimes delete wallpapers undiscriminedly (<-- wonder if I spelled that right ).

Anyway, don't give up. You can always try to improve your wallpaper, listening to the advice of the guys who posted here. And remember that in the end *you* decide what to change and what not to change... if some mod doesn't like your wallpaper and delete it again, then let that be that I'll be keeping my fingers crossed for you.

ah, i actually like the wall. i was actually cackling at the men in bleach. i have been planning to turn that scan into a wallpaper soon, but was thinking matrix instead of mib. um... i guess maybe darken or add a little effects to the stars? i can't really give feedback bc i like the wall so... good luck!