Quote by ShiNN84Huh. I care for
both. And I don't look exactly as those aspects. What
matters is if you like it or not, that's all... there can be different
reasons that lead you to like a wallpaper, personally I value both
aspects but in the end I just look at the final result. The wallpaper
has some minor flaws? I am not trashing it if I still like it and if it
has a nice concept. The wallpaper is flawless but is "unoriginal"? I am
not trashining it if I still like how everything has been executed.
This is my own point of view, of course.
Same here. Concept and technicality must work in harmony. And for the minor flaw thing, it's normal since this is
what art is all about. We can say it's almost perfect, but not absolutely perfect.
Concept is a creation from the mind but the case for originality is very much needed. Of course, anything new and unique
for sure leaves a striking first impression.
In terms of judging or deeper constructive critcism, quality and details are very significant factors on an astounding
artwork. "Judging" is not an easy task, by the way. It's not as instant as just taking a glance or two,
good judges narrow it all down. Organization, coordination, effects used, etc. This is where technicality comes
in.
Quote by karaI think both are very
important. The "techincal perfect" walls usually
impress me a bit more though, since it shows the skills and dedication
of the waller. Concept is also important as it shows the creativity of
the waller but good concept that's not backed with good skills will
ruin the wall. In my opinion anyway.
I also agree with kara said about having "good concept but not backed up with good skills ruins a wall." -A
good concept is worthless if it ends up screwed just because he/she is not equipped with the right skills. It would just
frustrate the artist because he won't be able to share that great idea with
others.
But I don't mean being harsh to beginners for I'm not a waller myself. As usual, there's always an
exemption to this category but I guess as time progresses, their abilities might enhance too if they really dedicate
themselves to this field and with the help of trusted critics.
These two can't be separated. One needs the other to create true art. Well, this is just what I think. ;)
