»

setting the record straight on EVA

Tagged under Neon Genesis Evangelion

This thread is closed for posting.

Ranga

Ranga

I am, I.

Cancel

many people do not fully understand Evangelion; however I have found somebody who understands more than most.

I did not write any of this I am giving credit to the one who did, I will send you the link on where I found this
here is what she says.

..............................................................................................................................


In defense of a vision: Anno's Evangelion
By: Sarah Davis

Note: I've seen the movie, people... The link to my opinions on it is right there at the bottom of the page, and has been there for no less than FOUR MONTHS. Probably longer. Before e-mailing me to complain about what I said concerning the film, check HERE for a review of it. Most of the e-mail I get is redudant whining about how I mistreated, misunderstood, and misrepresented the movies.


Shinseiki Evangelion is one of the most popular anime currently available in English. It has succeeded as a Japanese television series both in Japan and around the world. Evangelion is one of those few anime that can appeal to nearly anyone. It has everything it needs to succeed…

Or so it seems.

The unfortunate aspect of Shinseiki Evangelion (Eva) is that most fans love the series with unbound glee and affection until the last two episodes. Throughout the series prior to that point it has all the plot, character development, subplots, emotional impact, great animation, good music, cool mecha, and more to make it an astounding sight to behold. Then the final two episodes occur. After everything has presumably been resolved the series takes a sudden turn. The Eva Units disappear. The combat is over. The series becomes almost awkward, it is so cerebral. The characters analyze themselves throughout, peering into the depths of their own souls. It leads to nothing but a series of "congratulations" from the cast, in the direction of Shinji Ikari, the protagonist. It seems strange that a series which began with such a bang would end in such a somber, personal note. Suddenly it shifts dramatically. All the sentai elements have been erased, replaced with self-analysis of by the characters.

Many fans despise this original ending and prefer the movies that were made proceeding an outpouring of no less than rage from the fans who could not grasp or understand the end. What was the point in Shinji being told he could make his future his own? Where was the Third Impact? What became of everyone? Was this any way to end a series that was so promising? The answer to that final question: Yes.

I’ve not seen the movies, nor do I feel particularly compelled to do so. I’ll certainly buy or rent copies eventually, but for now I am content to study Anno’s masterpiece, Eva, without being burdened by the fan service movies. The fact is that everything about Eva is ultimately very atypical. Where any other series would have designed Shinji to be a lecher, a girl-magnet, a smart-ass, a genius, or otherwise unnatural, Eva created in Shinji the archetype of humanity and I respect that. Does that make sense? Shinji was everyone. He felt despair, solitude, unhappiness, depression, and so many other things that so few anime series bother to touch, let alone attempt to conquer. Shinji is "every man," so to speak. Anyone can relate to his problems. His father abandoned him, his mother died, he was shy and could not make friends easily, he was picked-on, he was an outcast… The list goes on. Shinji embodies everything that makes a human frail. He wants nothing more than to be accepted. Eva ends by portraying Shinji as someone who realizes this – that he only wants to be liked – but also as someone who wants to grow out of that stage.

The end of the original twenty-six episode television series had Shinji, Misato, Rei, and Asuka coming to grips with all the troubles they faced. Shinji wanted to be accepted, Misato did not want to be left alone, Rei wanted to know she was needed, and Asuka wanted to see that she was loved. They were all left alone at one point, or were expendable. All of them needed reassurance. The final episodes of Eva were centered around them voicing their fears. This much is evident from the dialogue and imagery. In the end when they see that they have self-worth outside of what others see in them and of them they are congratulated. Yui, Gendo, Ritsuko, Kaji, Maya, and a slew of other cast members tell Shinji he has done a good job.

So… what’s the point? The point was that Eva was never about the Eva Units. It was about the need for acceptance. It was about Shinji piloting an Eva for praise, Asuka piloting an Eva to be special, Rei piloting an Eva to be needed, and Misato guiding them because she had a hole in her own soul which needed to be filled with their presence. Once the need for the Evas was gone all of this crumbled and their worlds fell apart. Shinji, Rei, Asuka, and Misato were not special anymore. Then they were left to analyze themselves and try to find a new sense of self-worth.

That is the point of Eva. That no matter what your academic or social achievements may be, and no matter what position you hold for a job, you are unique. You do not need to rely on the praise of others to be such. Shinji regurgitated the praise he received from others so that he could relive the experiences. How many people do that? How many children post their successful tests on refrigerator doors and keep them there for months because it was their best grade? How many Olympic contenders keep gleaming trophies shining brightly in their cases for all their lives to remember that instant of glory when they crossed the finish line, got the goal, or made the leap? How many? Have you done such a thing? Of course you have. Everyone has. You keep old tests because they were done well. You cherish essays for which you were praised. You keep the trophies and monuments to your successes tightly locked and safe in a cabinet where they can be recalled but not damaged. And what happens if one of those trophies falls to the ground and is shattered? What if the test gets soaked by water and becomes illegible? What then? What evidence do you have that you ever did anything great?

That is Eva.

Why does so much discontentment come from this? Perhaps because Anno’s portrayal of the human psyche strikes a chord. We hate to recognize ourselves in Shinji because he is a "wimp," or a "wuss." He’s a "sissy." He’s "pathetic." He "whines too much." Does he really? Or do we just claim he is a pitiful little child because seeing ourselves reflected in someone like him is painful? Shinji is not perfect, which is what makes him intriguing. He does not have many outstanding qualities. He pilots an Eva well. And this means..? What? No one on Earth will ever pilot an Eva. Mayhaps Shinji piloting the Eva was a figment of his imagination, a way to make himself stand out. In reality none of those things occurred. To aid him he created characters who were branches of himself. Misato is the one who wants to keep others near. Asuka is the one who wants to push them away. Rei is the one who wants to know she can be near. Shinji is all of them as a single person, the not-quite-happy medium of the group. They all represent a single person who has one flaw: The raw, human need to be loved.

When the last Apostle/Angel, Kaworu, was killed, what made Shinji exceptional vanished. He then had to look into himself for what he was missing. He lacked something and he feared this. It made him uncomfortable. Was he strange? Did others view him that way? Would they like him? Questions such as these poured into his mind.

How many people have, at some point, wanted to fade away and die because they felt no one liked them? Suicides are not uncommon due to factors such as this. Anno explored this in the deepest sense. He related to the audience his deepest feelings. His regrets, his desires, and so much more. His mind is in Eva. When we watch Shinji, we watch Anno. It was such a personal view that it’s frightening. What would anger me, if I were Anno, is to see people take my memoir and bastardize it because the grand finale did not involve impressive sights. Anno offered us no less than himself and so many fans turned around and cried foul. The animation was not perfect, the music was not ideal, the last two episodes were boring… How many of these complaints have we all heard many times? For all Anno’s work, he was repaid with a lot of whining and ten dozen movies that are most certainly not his true vision. They ended in a way that would catch eyes and leave fans in awe. My, my, isn’t that huge Rei cool looking? Isn’t it sweet to see Asuka has regained her mental capacity and Shinji is alone with her, the next Adam and Eve… How cute.

Or, rather...

How absolutely, sickeningly, pathetically TYPICAL. How many anime end too much like that? There is no originality in that ending. To me this is just a poor attempt to make up for Anno trying to give us something more than just another Monsters vs. Big Robots anime. Eva TV is reality. Eva movies are fantasy. [For a clarification on these specific comments, go HERE.]

But I digress. I can only ask you this: How would you rather see the series end? As Anno intended, with analysis of who we all are and what we want and need? Or with lots of neat explosions and ultra-obvious answers to the enigmas? Do you want to think or have it spelled out for you in bold writing? If you hate to think, Eva wasn’t for you in the first place.

I’ll leave this on that note. Flame away, my friends.

................................................................................................................


here is the link to where I found this.

http://www.secondimpact.net/vision.shtml

You say I fool myself
But better me than being a fool for some one else

N2Heiki

N2Heiki

Devil Bats' Quarterback

Cancel

Read this too! it's very interesting
http://magazine.anipike.com/index.php?article=66

Signature
	Image
HiruMamo!!! Yaaaa- Haaaa-

Cohex

Cohex

Junglist

Cancel

hmm i am yet to read it but it looks like a good find..i might read it after i finish my assingment

hongrboi

hongrboi

getting pwned by school

Cancel

Thank you! This is great! Now i understand why they had that second last or last episode where Shinji just kept on saying 'It's my fault' or something over and over again throughout the whole episode with half the episode full o f text. I thought they just ran low on budget Xp.

Quote by N2HeikiRead this too! it's very interesting
http://magazine.anipike.com/index.php?article=66

This one was interesting too! *goes to rewatch eva*

"Once two star have collided and return to their orbit, the chance of colliding again is infinity small, for there are many other possible collisions."
Signature Image
Latest wall ::A Void in my Heart::

Ranga

Ranga

I am, I.

Cancel

Quote by N2HeikiRead this too! it's very interesting
http://magazine.anipike.com/index.php?article=66

I read almost all of it but I couldn't read any more. I just can't agree with what this guy is saying.

You say I fool myself
But better me than being a fool for some one else

Cancel

I believe that Eva isn't just a mecha anime but it's an anime concerning more on the interactions of the characters. Yes, many were disappointed with episode 25 and 26 but that's why there's the movies. I usually don't read articles about Eva but there's a site I found that contains many articles. I think it's Evamonkey or something.

Signature
	Image

Cancel

I didn't like 25 and 26. I think they needed to put a close to their phycological developments, but they could have done it more subtly and in less than two whole episodes. I wanted to see more of the events on the "out side world" than just what was going on in their heads.

Modi

Modi

God of battle rage

Cancel

Many fans despise this original ending and prefer the movies that were made proceeding an outpouring of no less than rage from the fans who could not grasp or understand the end. What was the point in Shinji being told he could make his future his own? Where was the Third Impact? What became of everyone? Was this any way to end a series that was so promising? The answer to that final question: Yes.


after i read that right there i stoped reading i fully understood the point of the first and real ending i understand why she doesnt think the final movie was not needed but fact of the matter is...screw that ending the series like that just left to much undone, i needed closeur on most of what was put into the end of evangelion and so has ALL of everyone i've talked to about it weither they understood the end or not the movie STILL gave what was needed to be able to walk away from it all without being well...kinda torchered by all that was left completly unsaid or done.

Komm Susser Tod
the sad wish of a warrior
with noone and nothing
to fight for.

quills

quills

sleepy dreamer

Cancel

thank you for sharing this. i think this is really really a great piece of writing which explained EVA and what author's intended on wanting his audiences to know. It's so nice to see it throughly explained and laid-out. Easy to understand, simplifies the EVA story. And i definitely agree, that the last two episode were spetacular.

(\ /)
( . .)
c('')('')
This is Bunny. Copy Bunny into your signature to help him on his way to world domination.

davew30

davew30

I ate mythology and slept

Cancel

I have to be honest, I too was one the fans who didn't like the first ending or any ending provided for that mater. In part this is largely due to my inability to fully understand the ending of EVA. I too had really high hopes of the ending, and after reading this I find EVA to be much better and that the original ending was probably the best.

Stop deaths on the road, drive on the pavement!!!

Etron

Lukav

Cancel

i didnt like last two episodes of evangelion the first time i see it, but when i stop to think about the other final, it's so empty so mecha's animes.
i didnt have this point of view shared here, but i make a new ending for me, mixing the two ends in me head, and i think this one is really great...
although, i accord with everything in "In defense of a vision: Anno's Evangelion"...
very good! thanx

N2Heiki

N2Heiki

Devil Bats' Quarterback

Cancel

if you wanna konw more, just read the "red cross book" here http://www.motorballer.org/redcross.html

Signature
	Image
HiruMamo!!! Yaaaa- Haaaa-

Cancel

I liked both the series and movie endings...

Cancel

Finally someone says it...Eva is a thinking show(one of the few). The first ending was boring but so frighteningly deep.

lianppoper

lianppoper

[Free Bird]

Cancel

i love eva, all of it. including episode 25 and 26.
in fact, i kept on watching them because i found them very interesting. :)

Signature
	Image

Cancel

that is the best thing i've ever read :)

Cancel

Yeah, maybe I'm the one who complain about the ending in Ep 25 & 26... but after I read above, maybe I must rethink about that end. Something miss from my POV... th'x for bringing this topic.

I shall die before it's all begin... for I don't have any future with me...

Cancel

Actually, I like the two last episode of Evangelion best of all the series. They are thought-provoking, unexpected and cathartic. I do wonder whether Anno has some Oedipus complex though, from the sheer number of characters who have a problem with their mother/father.

Spystreak

Retired Moderator

Spystreak

The Grim Reaper

Cancel

Don't bump old threads especially if you have nothing relavent to contribute to the discussion going on.

Fools You Can't Escape from The Grim Reaper. Your Only Chance for Escape Is Death. Bye Bye Now
Signature
	Image
Your Ignorance Will Be Your Own Downfall.

page 1 of 1 19 total items

Back to In-depth Discussions | Active Threads | Forum Index

Only members can post replies, please register.