i thought she was a rather useless character. I kinda wanted her to die with her Zaku in that one battle
Tagged under Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Destiny
Who do you like Lunamaria the best with?
- Shinn and Lunamaria
- 60 votes
- Yolan and Lunamaria
- 2 votes
- Rey and Lunamaria
- 13 votes
- Arthur and Lunamaria
- 6 votes
- Athrun and Lunamaria
- 11 votes
- No one, bitch deserves to die. ^^ <3
- 36 votes
Only members can vote.
This thread is closed for posting.
page 4 of 4 « Previous 1 2 3 4 79 total items
-
- Dec 17, 2007
- Gallery
-
Well i do think there's was lack of back story on Luna in the series, as for the chasing of Athrun..well she's what 16 or 17 years old. and ya i thought that was kinda annoying too, but if I recall teens do that kind of stuff, going from one crush to another..
As for spying on the meeting...you're not question why but do and die..(soldiers duty) especially considering the nature of the information she gathered for the captain. and in turn all it did was confuse Luna in the end when she had asked questions and then was told to forget about it.
As for going to Shinn after her sister was "dead" thats just dumb, i didn't like that idea of that plot line. Even though she possibly felt alone and had confused emotions...most people still wouldn't go to the person who had supposed to have killed your sister.
Now as for having her as character in the series...the writers probably thought they should have another 4 zaft pilots like they did in the first series...GS (Athrun,Izak,Nichol and Dearka) GSD (Shinn,Rey,Luna and Athrun) and in both series they kill off one pilot, just Rey turns out to be one to die.
But in the end Luna is basically a filler character they put in, gave no back story on or anything so ya no body is really gonna like her as character or hate her (at least should be no reason to) so ya my vote is not dead but alone
- Dec 23, 2007
- Gallery
-
Damn it's been so long since I've really checked this thread out. Glad to see that it's compelled a lot of people to express their opinions, and to give details as to why they feel that way. Too many threads in the anime sections have posts with little 'substance'. It's nice to see the different perspectives, or in some cases, the similar ones. ^^
It's been a while since Destiny aired, and my feelings for Lunamaria have subsided. I read over what I said, and I do think I come off as harsh. lol! My bad, but this was always intended to be an opinion thread, and I wouldn't want anyone to censor their opinion on a fictional character... so yeah, kinda glad I just let it all out. xD
@Yuchya
It's cool that you like Lunamaria, especially if you can connect with her character. Because of that you were able to see qualities in Lunamaria that I wasn't. You seem like a nice person, and I'd like to be able to see Lunamaria differently as well... but even now, I still rather dislike her. xD But meh, what can ya do?Quote by ahziraOK..I don't like lunamaria because she did ridicilous things and that.And thats not because im a shinnxstellar fan(shinstel looks more compatible together i mean they look like awww..so cute together)
i don hate her,i juz don like the shinnxluna pairing.I juz saw Lunamaria as a bystander or something related 2 it.She was given a big role in the series and yet she did nothing 4 the plot development.
And if shinn did love luna,y did he saw stellar in a dream or as a ghost?And naked 4 that matter..uhhhh y did i add that...anyways Stellar did more than Luna she somehow 'comforted' shinn.I mean if you look at her playing in the water or dancing don't u feel relaxed?ok maybe that was juz me..And Stellar gave shinn a reason to carry on fighting.And if i remember correctly shinn was blinded by the rage of losing stellar and his sister that he did not see Luna 'blocking' Athrun.He almost killed her.
ok that's juz my opinion.no offense lunafans/shinnxluna fans
and the person who created this thread.U are so awesome in expressing ur thoughts on Luna and for that i support ur opinnions!SHINNXSTELLAR FOREVER!
Looking back, I do think that my preference for Shinn/Stellar had a significant impact on my dislike for Lunamaria, along with my feelings towards Meyrin. I found the S/S relationship to be very pure, based on both of their needs for someone to love and to find 'salvation' in being needed and protecting each other (more-so from Shinn's perspective). Along with the tragedy of Stellar's existence and Shinn's past, I just found their connection to be very beautiful and touching, which for me, is a stark contrast to Lunamaria and Shinn, which I saw to be mostly based on guilt, loneliness, uncertainty, etc. But I acknowledge now that, like S/S, their relationship was also based on need... for companionship and a place to feel safe. And looking at it like that, I've come to accept the pairing in a much more positive manner.
EDIT :: O_o
There was a lot more to my post when I hit the submit button... =/
Anyway, while I view the pairing differently, I still can't empathize with Luna deciding to seek comfort in Shinn... and of course, nothing has changed about the lack of development and missed opportunities to really develop her character.
- Dec 25, 2007
- Gallery
-
uh i thing that the only reason she's wit shinn is bcause SUNRISE doesn't want him to be a lousy main character. first everyone thought he was a protagonist, then he became an antagonist, then athrun finally knock some sense into his brains and THEN he can finally think rationally. i mean after all he did, i jus keep hoping he died somewhere between da series but his da 1 of da main characters and also SUNRISE had to do something to lift up his name and wat better way than to pair him up wit a filler character. no offense but luna doesn't do anything much except stalk athrun n she finally got her big break when she hook up wit shinn. suprisingly, they didn't sleep together like kira n fllay. huh. stellar was da best thing dat happen cause i finally got to see the gentle side of him. i mean have u ever seen shinn smile gently bcause of luna?
I also think dat SUNRISE wanted to spice things up and they made meyrin liking athrun. the way im telling it seems to be like im bashing the hawke's sister but im not. i don't mind their character. after all they're not even real. i;m just not satisfied with the way SUNRISE made the plot. so the chance of shinn getting jolly wit luna is probably high cause i mean who else would they end up with? unless stellar comes back alive or shinn dies (im crossing my fingers for both)- Jul 17, 2008
- Gallery
DarknessEmperor1337
Emperor of darkness
-
Luna doesn't deserve anyone. Her realtionship with Shinn is too wierd because it is like, "Even though you killed by sister, I still love you."
Give me reason, to prove me wrong, to wash this memory clean.
- Currently watching: Naruto
- Jul 14, 2009
- Gallery
- Anime Watchlist
-
Lunamaria isn't shallow i think but not too bright. i mean she saw and hear the convo between Kira, Cagalli, and Athrun and still thought Athrun was a traitor, also was still fooled by Meer being the "real" Lacus. Also Shinn like kills her sister and she like falls in love with him. I dunno, SEED Destiny really doesn't make a whole lot of sense.
- Currently watching: Mobile Suit Gundam 00
- Jul 14, 2009
- Gallery
- Anime Watchlist
-
please don't bump old threads. closed
EGAO! Distant Destiny!:.:devART:.:PokeWalls:.:C&C:.:P-o-R:.:Vectory:.:DSC:.:Simple-ism
Join which?waller round 12!!- Currently watching: Mushishi, Cross Ange, Log Horizon
- Jul 14, 2009
- Gallery
- Anime Watchlist
page 4 of 4 « Previous 1 2 3 4 79 total items
Back to In-depth Discussions | Active Threads | Forum Index
Only members can post replies, please register.