Well if you're looking for "haunting" music, I have a few( yeah right" suggestions ^_^')
although some of it aren't anime OSTs, they're definitely in the category that you mentioned. I'll give
you names of specific songs, and/or albums/compilations/compositions:
1) " Haunted "--Blair Witch 2 soundtrack( pun intended ^_^')
2) Final Fantasy: Advent Children soundtrack( some are not " haunting " music, but there are other
compositions in there that'll fit with what you're looking for... ;)) i.e., The Promised Land :D
3) FF8 soundtrack collections, especially " Time Compression ", " The Extreme ", and " Silence
and Motion "
4) Witch Hunter Robin OST, " Shell ",and " Half-pain "( my favourite )
5) Ergo Proxy ( pretty much all the contents are haunting )
6) Turn A-Gundam, i.e., Yoko Kanno's composition called " Moon "
7) Noir ( pretty much all of the OST )especially, " Secret Game ", " Le Grand Retour ", " Canta
Per Me ", and " Salva Nos "
8) Albums of Within Temptation like " Mother Earth " and Silent Force "
9) FF9, " The Place I long to Return To ", and " Song of Memories "
10) Silent Hill OST ( chills down my spine...)
11) Blood the Last Vampire OST
Individual songs/compositions:
1) Sadness and Sorrow( Naruto )-based on the short piece called Hokage's Funeral
2) " Space Lion "--Yoko Kanno's composition for Cowboy Bebop
3) " Ensei ", " Memories of Fanelia " and " Sora's Folken "
4) " Lilium Est ", " Broken Wings " and " Anna Ni Issho Datta No Ni--Athrun's Feelings
"
4) Max Payne Theme from the Official Max Payne Soundtrack
5) " Sora ", " Frozen Flower " and " Brothers "
Those are only some of what I listen to that can be considered " haunting ", hope this selection helps!
:D
--
" Death is but perchance to dream. A dream that lasts for eternity. "--Vincent Volaju