Black Cat.. Is the manga or the anime better?

Tagged under Black Cat

Which is better?

Anime
15 votes
Manga
41 votes
Can't choose, both great!
8 votes

Only members can vote.

This thread is closed for posting.

page 1 of 2 1 2 Next » 32 total items

Cancel

I love them both but I prefer the anime. :)

I was just wondering which one you prefer?

  • Mar 24, 2006

Kairi-Hearts

Kairi-Hearts

~sitting in the silence~

Cancel

The manga definitly. has a wide storyline, lots of comedy and lots lots lots lots lots of things that didn't appear in the anime. especially when you need at least 19 manga books to defeat Creed and in the anime 19 eps. I mean...!

jasaiyajin

jasaiyajin

-repeat-

Cancel

manga hands down


EDIT: HEY I VOTED MANGA, NOT ANIME!

-repeat-

  • Mar 24, 2006
Cancel

Yeah... I read the manga and still watching the anime. What a disappointment that the series is so short! They missed so much stuff out. I wish they would've spent just a little bit more time on the anime. Oh well, Train is awesome!

  • Mar 28, 2006

laurent

laurent

..:: Kuro ::..

Cancel

The manga, no doubt. First of all I think that the plot of the manga is way better (I agree with what Kairi said), and so is the character design. I mean, just look at Train. He looks way wilder and cooler in the manga. I must admit that I even was dissapointed when I saw that they had turned Train in the anime from a cool cat killer (manga) into a friendly looking teenager. The manga managed to dazzle me right from the start, but the anime didn't. That doesn't mean I'm not enjoying watching the anime, it's really good, but the manga is soooooooooooooo much better !

..::Kira::..

Signature Image

Cancel

Manga! Manga's are usually better than the anime especially when it comes to the story since the story is frequently compressed when it comes to the anime.

  • Mar 28, 2006
Cancel

i like both of them

  • Mar 30, 2006

Rinslet

Rinslet

Yorozuya

Cancel

Anime sux! i almost cry when saw Train´s design, and the plot...man, what where they thinking? Train/Sven friendship is all messed up, skiped great situations, turned upside down things (never forgive them for changing the dinosaur episode, Train all dressed up... ;-; that was priceless!) and now, Creed/Sephiria was a joke, right?

Still liked the music =) at least.

Sry, i´m in a awfull mood D:

soujiokita

soujiokita

Super Kawaii

Cancel

Definitely the manga! the anime was way too short and they cut out lots of good parts. The beggining was different form the manga too. The anime was pretty good, but there were so many parts that were gone.

Signature
	Image
My LJ
currently not[/not] accepting avatar/sig/graphic requests

Cancel

The anime no doubts about that... The anime story has a way better explaining than the manga one..and for the design...no one can say that the manga's are better than those of the anime, like Creed in the first appearances. Anyway I agree that Black Cat is a great story both manga and Anime.

  • Apr 01, 2006

fallenfate

fallenfate

wherever fate leads me

Cancel

definitely the manga...
its takes longer to read and go through the scenes...more time to sit at stare at the pages...^^ plus the background stuff is missing from the anime...slightly changed. the original is always the best.

'Those who have wings, Fly your dreams'

zuruzuru zuruzuru
Signature
	Image

  • Apr 06, 2006

NightAngel

A dream box

Cancel

In my opinion, the manga is better, mopstly because the characters look a lot more mature. But I still loved the anime. I guess they are different and both good.

Face your fears, Live your dreams
Hana-Kimi-Love

Cancel

Manga is great. i prefer manga than the anime, but i still like the anime. for the beginning of the story i prefer the manga. Saya pop out too early in anime. but i enjoyed both of it.

  • Apr 09, 2006
Cancel

I do like anime, but with manga based anime (which is most of them), I find that the manga explains more of the story (Berserk for example). So I would have to say that manga is better (not taking away from anime, their great).

  • May 26, 2006

kingray100

kingray100

Ryu,the half demon

Cancel

Anime is better!who wants to read when u can watch the cool and great gaphics of anime?

  • Jun 17, 2006
Cancel

Manga because I prefer the storyline of the manga and the story begins with Train and Sven so it goes right to the point while the anime shows Trains past...

? ???? ?? ??? ???? ???? ?? ??? ??? ?? ? ????? ?? ?????

Cancel

I prefer manga, the story is clear and funnier than the anime
The anime starts with Train's past. B'coz of that,the story become a little bit dull. Plus the anime is too short so i feel disappointed.

  • Aug 19, 2006

Sarkanybaby

Chairman of The SB Pictures

Cancel

The manga is the best! The characters in the anime are sooooo dumb!
Poor Sven-chan... T____T

Cancel

Does anyone know who many volumes the manga is?

  • Apr 04, 2007
Cancel

lol the manga is 10 times better compared to the anime o-o.. But the anime brought out the relationship b/w saya and train better and its more emotional o-o... thats probably the only thing its better at xD... The anime changed the storyline and sorta pulled a weak full metal alchemist while it was at it -___-... would've been better if they animated the manga storyline T.T

Cancel

manga, lot more comedy there, and there is a lot of story, unlike the anime run, i wish it ran for more than 23. the ending was somewhat short too. it was lacking something. i bet they rushed it just to finish the run.

  • May 06, 2007
Cancel

Of course the anime is way better, coz Train Heartnet is much more handsome in the anime...he..he... :D

Cancel

Quote by PinksodaDoes anyone know who many volumes the manga is?


if im not mistaken its 20 volumes, and is available via torrents, or in www.mangaspot.com but only til volume 17 only. also it has one extra chapter where eve finally gets her official sweeper liscence with leons help. the manga however only runs till the creed train battle, no eden storyline.

  • May 16, 2007
Cancel

The anime is kinda short but i prefer watching it than reading about it. But i kinda agree, the anime is too short.

  • Oct 01, 2007

page 1 of 2 1 2 Next » 32 total items

Back to In-depth Discussions | Active Threads | Forum Index

Only members can post replies, please register.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Read more.