Who's the good girl in Kimi Ga Nozomu Eien? Mitsuki? Haruka?

Tagged under Kimi ga Nozomu Eien

page 1 of 1 17 total items

Cancel

Who's the antagonist? Who's the protagonist?
[img=http://i175.photobucket.com/albums/w137/ayafujiwara/Rumbling%20Hearts/Mitsuki.jpg]hayase mitsuki[/img]
Mitsuki? :o

[img=http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n227/mekunami/kimi_ga_nozomu_eien_5.jpg]haruka suzumiya[/img]
Or Haruka? :o :o :o

ATAndTruong

ATAndTruong

More To It Then Meets The Eye...

Cancel

That's a biased question from the start. Of course, the "good girl" is Haruka. Throughout the whole series, she maintains an image of purity and innocence. On the other hand, Mitsuki is presented as being desperate and manipulative. There's absolutely no room for doubt.

I think a better question would be, "Should Takayuki have picked Haruka, or was he right in picking Mitsuki?"

Signature
	Image
Ideas...without actions, are worthless.
Thanks to the wonderful k1ru for making my masterpeice of a webpage!

  • Oct 20, 2007
Cancel

Mitsuki. She helped Haruka with boyfriend, she helped Haruka

  • Jan 04, 2008
Cancel

ya haruka is the innocent one... shes the one who gets hurt more too... cause she never did anything wrong.... to be honest its mitsuki's fault and the guy... actually.. no .. mitsuki was jealous and stuff you know.... that. wench.. =/ can't help it..... BUT.... the guy is horny bastard XD

  • Jan 04, 2008
Cancel

i would have to say due to the way things turned out that theres kind of a weird 3 way thing going on so theres no actual protagonist or antagonist. theres no actual way to judge

  • Jan 05, 2008
Cancel

Quote by atahrvin17i would have to say due to the way things turned out that theres kind of a weird 3 way thing going on so theres no actual protagonist or antagonist. theres no actual way to judge

Yep, exactly.

Cancel

I think he should have picked Haruka.

  • May 01, 2008
Cancel

Answering the original question, I say Haruka is the good girl, because of her loyalty and bla bla bla for Takayuki, but Mitsuki stays with him in the end...what else sould Mitsuki had done?

Hasta la vista, condenadotes!!

Soy feliz y ya no necesito a mis Padrinos...Magicos!!!

Cancel

i think haruka is a good girl.

<a href="http://demons-of-rebellion.minitokyo.net/" target="_blank"><img src="http://img178.imageshack.us/img178/6294/demonsofrebellionbannerwj5.jpg"></img>

  • May 01, 2008
Cancel

Both. But I change Mitsuki Hayase.

  • May 28, 2008

Nickisherenow

SaRiteNite

Cancel

they are not at fault. A person who keeps him/herself from loving a loved one cannot survive.

Silent Warfare is my kind of war. Why? Because no one innocent gets hurt.

Terrorists aren't silent though. Bastards

  • Jul 14, 2008

Aiira

Linguistics

Aiira

SOON..

Cancel

If you are talking about the entire anime then I say it's Haruka ^^
But what I saw is that when Haruka wasn't involve in the accident yet, Mitsuki was pretty nice, until Haruka got into the accident that she became greedy and she wants everything for herself. ( that is my point of view ) ^^

Signature
	Image
CHERISH yesterday
DREAM tomorrow
LIVE today

Cancel

I agree with aiiroprincessnoel.
IMO Mitsuki is the "good girl" because Haruka was just being a B after the accident.

Lunariha

Lunariha

Glitter~♥

Cancel

Well, between the two choices you've given....I'll pick Haruka, of course XD
But then...in the early episodes (wherein Haruka's still in coma), her little sis Akane is the good girl. Well, she basically cared so much for her sis. XD

Signature
	Image
My Latest Artworks: Just Realized and My #7

Northy

Northy

Guys are human as well.

Cancel

I don't blame Mitsuki from going after the main lead, especially in light of the uncertainty of Haruka's condition and how long she would remain so. If I remember the anime correctly, she confessed after a full year had passed since the accident. And of course Haruka isn't to blame. She spent most of the show comatose, after all, and the rest almost blissfully unaware just how much time she had spent unconscious, plus just what had been going on while she did so. Basically, the ending was fairly satisfying, and I don't really begrudge our main lead the choice he made, nor do I necessarily think he did anything wrong by doing so.

That being said, I absolutely HATED the ridiculous amounts of melodrama I had to endure just to get through this show. Before I went and ordered the DVDs, I had read warnings that I'd probably be needing a lot of hankies to get through this show. In the end, it didn't make me sad and weepy at all. It made me frustrated and angry. It's a well-written show for the most part, but it set up a lot of contrivances and situations where the characters were free to act as spiteful and vindictive as possible within the borders of the "justifications" it provided. I will never ever watch this show again.

  • Dec 30, 2008
Cancel

I think that both girls are good girls... It's just the circumstances that made them unfortunate in various ways...

For me, I also think that Mitsuki was the right choice for the main character...

  • Jan 10, 2009
Cancel

Quote by yamamotoyohkoI think that both girls are good girls... It's just the circumstances that made them unfortunate in various ways...

For me, I also think that Mitsuki was the right choice for the main character...

I think the same think, they are both good girls, Mitsuki didn't do anything wrong she was in love with Takayuki since the start...

  • Mar 30, 2011

page 1 of 1 17 total items

Back to In-depth Discussions | Active Threads | Forum Index

Only members can post replies, please register.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Read more.