AND....HERE WE GO! :D
First of all THANKS to ALL PARTECIPANTS! Really! >.<
So let's start this pool :3
I repeat, once more time, that ALL MINITOKYO MEMBERS, and not only group's member
could vote!
All detailed info could be read under the spoiler in this topic, but since it seems to be
more confused that helped, just ignore it XD
Seriously let made it very simple:
- If you're a member that DIDN'T enjoy the contest, just write your rank, from your personal first place to
the last one! (so ALL ten entries shall be included!)
- If you're a member that actually ENJOYED the contest, made the same thing, but don't include your work in
your rank! And remember ALL partecipants HAVE TO made it, or you'll be DISQUALIFIED!
The jusdges for this contest will be RAFFACHAN (me XD)
and SRSN! You'll know about our votes at the end of the pool, when I'll
published the final rank with the winner :) This pool will be CLOSED on the 29
FEBRAURY AT MIDNIGHT GMT!
And these are all the entries of this contest! Please give a them a properly look and made
your rank! :D
How I wrote before they will receive an award the FIRST, the SECOND and the THIRD places
of the Final Rank.
But I'd like to add others little awards for:
- MT's members Choice ---> this award will be
given to the FIRST place of the pubblic pool's rank
- Judges Choice ---> this award will be given to the
FIRST place of judges' rank
These Awards will be obtain only from a "mathematical calculation", so if the
winner of this awards will be the same work, it will be only the proof that wallpaper is really good :3
PLUS, how I wrote in the last topic, the wallpaper that will be the FIRST PLACE of the
Final Ramkwill be used for made the new group's userpage lay :D
WELL, I think it's enough, isn't it? :p
If you have any question just ask! But if you're confused about the voting mode, just remember that it's
normal right now XD
WINNERS!
Aaaand here we go!
First of all thanks to ALL members that enjoyed this contest and all of them that voted in the pubblic pool! Thank you
so much!
Unfortunaly Jakuro didn't her rank, so I have to disqualified her work ç________________ç
Anyway, we have a tied...in the first place! o.o But it can't be helped, numebers decided it, so for the first
contest of this group, we actually have two "first place" winners :3 And I have to say that I'm happy
about that, because from my point of view, both these works deserved it!
So...this is the final rank!
FINAL RANK:
Spoiler (show)
1. Colour Note – RideOnMusic tied with Rissa-chi
1. Dyed Delusion - Rissa-chi tied with Rideonmusic
2. A Playact of sweetness – Aozoraskies
3. Going Under - espada
4. Dreamweaver – xangel0
5. Mario Bros. Fever – hitsuchan
6. Tempest –xkurumi
7. How to defeat a genius – SamB/ Stolen Colors – Mirtillo
Here there is the two judges ranks, srsn gave a comment only for her top 3, personally I prefered to give a comment for
all works ^_^
SRSN’s RANK:
Spoiler (show)
1. Dyed Delusion - Rissa-chi
- The color scheme used in this wallpaper is nice. There is a balance of light and dark color considering the limited
color pallete. Also, the typography execution is awesome and unique. Definitely fits the Persona anime theme.
2. Colour Note - RideOnMusic
- Even though the typography is ordinary in execution, it actually made use of sketchy-ness technique to bring out the
colors. With the limited pallete, RideOnMusic nailed it using gradients coupled with white, to turn something
colorful.
3. Going Under - espada
- The Monochromatic hues are vibrant and nice use of fading effect for gears is what can be seen in this wallpaper.
4. A Playact of sweetness - Aozoraskies
5. Dreamweaver – xangel0
6. prickly.personality - jakuro --> disqualified
7. Stolen Colors - Mirtillo
8. How to defeat a genius - SamB
9. Mario Bros. Fever - hitsuchan
10. Tempest -xkurumi
RAFFACHAN’s RANK:
Spoiler (show)
1.Dyed Delusion - Rissa-chi
I like…
All of this work! Really you did a great work, on the composition, how you used the colours, on the typo! *_* I love it!
The concept is awesome, too! :3
I don’t like…nothing :D
About the contest theme…it’s really perfect
2.Colour Note – RideOnMusic
I like…
All of this work,too XD Really…how you used the colours, how you played with contest rules and used it in the properly
way, the typography…the vector itself! Great work, really ;)
I don’t like…nothing :P
About the contest theme…your work fits it completely ^_^
3.Mario Bros. Fever – hitsuchan
I like…
The cutiness of this work! I really like how you made the composition, the background, the simple shading method, the
rainbow!
I don’t like…
Well the only thing that really I don’t like it’s the text in the center; I know that it’s the MarioBros’ font,
but I really prefer the textless version
About contest’s theme…
it’s okey, only the textversion doesn’t fit completely rules, since you couldn’t shading the colours between them
;)
4.Going Under – espada
I like…
The concept of the wall, and how you rapresented it! The vector is simple, but good
I like the effect of “fallen in the water”, and how you made it with that brushes! It’s pretty good and curious! I
like the way you made shadows on her hair, too.
I don’t like…
This version instead of the really first one XD I can’t tell you at that moment, but I really prefer the one you put
on MT! I can’t see it now, but I remember that the first time I saw you work I was like this --> *.*
Anyway, ignoring this, the really thing that I don’t like it’s the typo, it’ will be better without it ;)
About contest’s theme…
Your use of the palette is really cool, and I think you made really an improvement with this wall at that time
:3
5.How to defeat a genius – SamB
I like…
How you vectored the two scans, and how you united them (I expecially like the vector of the guy in the center) How
you distributed the palette colours, and how you used them!
I don’t like…
Some jagged lines, expecially black lines on papers and on characters; from my point of view it should be better without
then ;)
The typo, I really don’t like it >.< You could use a more better “ handwrintig font”…
Plus, the shadows on Akito&Moritaka faces…they should be darker under the hair, not the contrary XD
About contest’s theme…
The work fits exactly the rules, so nothing to say about it ;)
6.A Playact of sweetness – Aozoraskies
I like…
How you made all the composition! The moon, clouds, that stars and how you put the girl in it
How you used textures, expecially on her dress!
The typography, too :D It could be a little thing, but your sign it pretty cute like this, and it fits perfectly the
wall theme :3
I don’t like…
The lineart in some parts >.< How you wrote in the description, you have to improve that (I can understand, I
havbe the same problem ç_ç) Expecially on the girl face and hair there are a lot of jagged lines that ruined your work
:(
Plus there are some little dirty spot that could be erased.
About the theme contest…
You used pretty well the palette, I like expecially how you used it on the lineart, the final contrast between the
yellow lines and the colours inside is really good! But yeah, with that shading method you went a little out from the
rules, so I have to penalize you for that >.<
7.Stolen Colors – Mirtillo
I like…
How you used the palette that you chose! Expecially on Ai, the colours scheme is really good! :3
I like the vector itself, really clean and well done ^_^
I don’t like…
The compition…I mean..I like the idea, but for me it’s like you didn’t use the space in a good way >.< I
like every single object of this work, but I think they could be place better in the wall, expecially the typo..it’s
pretty random there.
About contest’s theme…
You work is another that fits the rules without problems, and I repeat, I really like how you used the palette colours
in this!
8.Dreamweaver – xangel0
I like…
Your drawing style *_* The concept and how you rapresented it! The little detailes of this work, the sketch-style, her
“hat” with that flowers and the wing :)
I don’t like…
How you used the palette colours ù.ù I mean I understand your idea, but it’s like you overpassed the main theme of
the contest! Don’t take my wrong, I really like your work, but I think you didn’t put enough effort on the contest
theme itself >.<
About the theme contest…
how I wrote before, for me you could use the same idea and take advange of theme contest more than this.
9.Tempest –xkurumi
I like…
The minimal design, the way you put the girl vector in the middle of the wall.
The typo, it’s simple but it fits the overall design of this work.
I don’t like…
The minimal design, too XD I’m not becoming crazy :p In fact I love it, but I think you could do a much better minimal
work than this ;)
About contest’s theme…
Your work is okey, too. The only thing is, since you made it quickly, how I said before, you didn’t your best in it
^_^ or better it’s what I feel about it
[color=#ffefb5]10.Prickly.personality – jakuro --> disqualified
I like…
How you cut the original image, and how you put it in the final composition. It’s pretty simple, but it’s good,
too.
I like how you combined the palette’s colours and the black background.
I don’t like…
Her eyes, I know that you just vectored the original one, but they don’t have any depth, and they’re really too much
“black”.
The vector is some part, it isn’t so good how I know that you can do
The way that you used patterns, they’re in the right place, but I don’t like especially the one on the rose, it
seems to be “stretched” o.o
The typography like that, it’s a little too much simple, you could chose some better font >.<
About contest’s theme…
You used in the right way the palette, expecially on the patterns, but I have the overall feeling that in this wall you
didn’t “your best” :(
Final rank from both judges' votes
Spoiler (show)
1. Dyed Delusion - Rissa-chi[/color]
2. Colour Note – RideOnMusic
3. Going Under – espada
4. A Playact of sweetness – Aozoraskies
5. Mario Bros. Fever – hitsuchan
6. How to defeat a genius – SamB
7. Dreamweaver – xangel0/Stolen Colors – Mirtillo
8. Tempest –xkurumi
And here there is the final rank from all members' votes!
Spoiler (show)
1.Colour Note – RideOnMusic
2. Dyed Delusion - Rissa-chi
3. Dreamweaver – xangel0
4. A Playact of sweetness – Aozoraskies
5. Tempest –xkurumi
6. Going Under - espada
7. Mario Bros. Fever – hitsuchan
8. Stolen Colors – Mirtillo
9. How to defeat a genius – SamB
To understand how I obtained the final rank, just download this excel file.
AWARDS
Top three
Spoiler (show)
Members Choice
Spoiler (show)
Judges Choice
Spoiler (show)
Soooo...about the fact that I said that the first place's wallpaper will be use for the new graphic of the group,
since we have two winners, I will made two graphics and I will switch them every week, until we'll have a new
wallpaper's contest winner :3
In the meanwhile I opened 3 NEW CONTESTs! Take a look in this topic! There you can find all the info that you need to enjoy them
:3
The last time I forgot to welcome new members >.< Sorry guys! So a warm welcome to:
Well it's all for now :3 THANK AGAIN PEOPLE! I'M HAPPY HOW THE GROUP IS GOING
ç__________ç