Login

Login

Need to register? Lost password?

Options

Advertisements

Advertisements

 

Final Fantasy Games - A different opinion

Music & Movies

Minitokyo » Culture & Entertainment Fora » Music & Movies  Final Fantasy Games - A different opinion

page 1 of 2

I feel like I'm the only person within my 10mile radius that doesn't think FF games are great. I played through 8, 10 and a bit of 12 on PS2 and I don't really see the big fuss.

First of all, random encounters are annoying. I can only fight the exact same battle so many times before it gets boring. The items to reduce random encs don't come till late in the game. The lack of cinematic skip in 8 and 10 was bad too. I couldn't get myself to play the games again. The stories don't really impress me. I've seen anime with more intense story telling. The stories aren't bad by any means. The long GF summons in 8, the slightly shorter aeon summons in 10 and the girly transformations in 12 all got repetitive. How do people sit and play this game for 50 hours watching the same GF animation over and over again? (especialy in 8 where they are pretty damn long). I don't find the gameplay to be complex at all. You don't have enough control over your character's development. Plus the games are all pretty linear. Often times, getting a game over means you got to redo 5-30 mins of stuff. In FFX, the part before I fight yunalesca was especially annoying. Each time I lost, I had to sit through a really long cinematic. Same with the final boss.

Now I admit that the graphics are top notch (except for the in-game characters in 8). But good graphics and godly cinematics didn't cut it for me. I wanted a fun game, not a movie. I liked the fantasy elements in these games but the gameplay is too tedious for me to endure.

Yeah, a zillion FF fans are probably going to start flaming now.... :)
Is it possible that someone feels the same way I do? Post quickly!!

I must agree that FF VIII is terrible with the battles. FF X wasn't so terrible in terms of repetitiveness because the battles were fast paced. I think things just became focused more on graphics after FF VII. That is why my favourite Final Fantasy game is probably FF VI! Go SNES graphics! :)

One thing you should know about the Final Fantasy series is that each new game is pratically a different game, except for ffx-2, which is the only direct sequel. Each game has a new storyline, battle system (for the most part), characters. The similar elements that are in all of the Final Fantasy's are the names of most of the spells, some of the enemies, the items, the re-occuring character Cid, and sometimes your basic plot to 'save the world'. Don't get me wrong, I like the Final Fantasy series, but that's because in my opinion they're all pretty good games, aside from the name. The gameplay and the storyline are usually pretty good, but the reason why it's not entirely complex is because it needs to be convenient, in other words, easy enough to get right into the action without having to read the manual or remember a lot of stuff. The only Final Fantasy series that I can think of with a complex gameplay is the Final Fantasy Tactics series. I also agree with you, I though FF8 was crap, because of the gameplay.

Square-Enix is basically milking the Final Fantasy name for what it's worth. As I had said earlier, each Final Fantasy game is a practically new game, with the exception of the trademark elements from previous series. All of the games aren't perfect, but in my opinion for the most part they're good if not great games and would be even if they didn't have the Final Fantasy name tagged onto it.

You know what makes a great game? When the storyline is only as good as it's gameplay. ^_^

<lol> I hear you. XD I've only played 10, and some of eight. 10-2 doesn't appeal to me much. :P (<--just prefers playing as a male chara...though I can't say Tidus counted as much of one), and while the graphics are great (agreed), they're not -totally-gripping- stories. And...(and I'm probably going to get shot for this, too) I liked Kingdom Hearts better hands down anyways. :) I'm immature, sue me.

"milking for what they're worth" sounds good and accurate. Probably a helluva lot, too. :) If I was them, I'd be doing the same.

imo the ones u played werent one of the better ffs. 8 just sucked and 10 wasnt that great either. i only played 10-2 to get all the dresspheres. you should try playing ffvi and vii


Quote: imo the ones u played werent one of the better ffs. 8 just sucked and
10 wasnt that great either. i only played 10-2 to get all the
dresspheres. you should try playing ffvi and vii


Each to their own but... I liked 8 way more than 7.

ok first of all it doesnt sound like your a big fan or rpgs but i may be wrong. of your not then that is one good reason why you wouldnt like FF. also as others have said you have actually played the worse FFs. 5, 6 , and 7 were my personal fav but then again a majority of the FF fans out there have played the ones you have played only. so anyways, i agree with you on that the FFs you played are nothing special and i never saw why they get so much of a fanbase. there are so many better rpgs out there and like you said i hate the fact that these crappy FFs of recent take all the attention

I'll start with saying that I don't really play RPG's, and the only Final Fantasy I've played is a wee bit of VII. But I can relay to you the option of my RPG loving friends.

From what I hear, 8 and 10 are the worse of the series. 9 and X-2 aren't so great either. They really like 5, 6 (this one being the best), 7, and maybe 4 too.

I can, however, totally agree with what Trowble said about Square-Enix really milking the "Final Fantasy" title. You ever see The Spirits Within? Perfect example. And it seems that any given year, if a FF game was released in it, it gets RPG of the year with the popular gaming publications no matter how good it was. Kind of bothersome.

Quote: Each to their own but... I liked 8 way more than 7.

Same same! The graphics in 8 sucked... Thats true... But I love the story line XD

The Spirits Within was a big finanical loss for square.

perhapes they just out of ideas on the story line, so they try to focus more on the graphic to interst the gamer,
but i have to agree that 8, 10, and X-2 suck, esspecially X-2, just seeing the preview i already loss my interest to play it.

That's okay if you don't like FF. Even me, an FF fan have my dislikes ie FF X-2 and 8. Luckily for you, not all RPGs have random encounters.

Everyone has his/her own taste.

The games you have played is in my opinon the worst ones in the series. Final Fantasy VII and Tactics are the only ones I really like in the series, but you are right; Final Fantasy is overrated. Well...if you want to play an RPG you've got to have a lot of patiense. I myself play them for the extensive storyline that you most often find in RPGs (yes, there are exceptions).

I love this game!!! I have played all the ff series... well all of them have the same concept but different approach... I think this game rocks~!

Final Fantasy 4 is my favourite out of all the FF games, just becaus ea game has nice graphics doesn't mean its better than something with a phenominal storyline and good gameplay! Out of the newer FF games I like 9 the best, and am waiting for 12 since the guy who did Final Fantasy Tactics (I <3 FFT) is doing 12 so it might not suck
well here's hoping it doesn't anyways XD *knocks on wood*

Here's my RPG picks:
Earthbound
Secret of Mana
Chrono Trigger
Final Fantasy 4
Xenogears (play this, screw Xenosaga :p)
Persona 1 & 2
Bahamut Lagoon

I liked all the final fantasy games i have played, as they were different to the other games in my house (mostly my brothers). I have loved the story and i like learning stuff as the characters learn it. The only problem is i keep getting stuck and no one can help me get out of it! In ff x im stuck at Evae, he is really hard he kills me just before i kill him!

I love Final Fantasy! The graphics, story, characters and stuff!!! XD.....but the battle system is too repetitive.

Anyway, I LOVE THIS game!!!

  • Rex
  • 4y 15wk ago

final fantasy has been degrading ever since 8 IMO

i liked 7 and 8.......but after that....i only found each of the games so-so

and you don't have to fight alot of random battles in FF8, since u get diablo quite early in the game, i got though the entire game with squall at lvl 11......thx to the junction system XD

if u want a more interactive battle....i think you should try out Star Ocean: A Second Story for ps1, or wait for Star Ocean: Till end of time for ps2 which is suppose to come out in august (hope they don't delay)

Well...you've only played a few FF games...you've got to play some of the other ones too and beat the whole game. Final Fantasy is one of the greatest RPGs out there, well, maybe not the greatest, but one of the good ones. Maybe you don't like it, but for us RPGers, it's a good game. I don't think FF VIII was that great and FF X-2 is somewhat pointless O_o. Yeah, some of the games sucked, but you've got to try the other ones out there too. You can't just base your opinion on those three that you've played.

I personally like Final Fantasy VII not because of graphics or anything, but because of the storyline.

Someone said something about each of the FF games were different, right? Well, I heard that the creator is going to keep creating one until he ummm "perfects" the game or something. So each of the games are different for a reason. They're different because each one is being improved or the creator is trying experimenting with all of them to see which one everyone likes. T_T Don't take my word for it though, this is what I heard from someone. That person could be wrong =p

I love FF vi-x. Yes, I even loved the often bashed FF viii. I haven't played FF XI because online gaming for FF is too different for my taste--though it is intriguing to say the least. And FF X-2 was...okay. I mean, the storyline was the weakest of the franchise (though not bad compared to other RPGs) and the whole thing of getting 100% completion was really frustrating--I swear it pissed me off so many times.

I'm looking forward to the day when Square Enix makes an FF game bringing back a large cast like FF VI or FF VII. :)

But if you want to try an FF that isn't simply button-mashing and random fights, play FF Tactics. Unless you hate tactic/strategy RPGs too. XD

Whats wrong with X-2? There's nothing wrong with the game system. In fact, the system is a step up. It's just the girlish, light-heated story that you people don't like (I don't like it much either). But look at whats improved.

1. Finally you can skip some in-game cinematics. The 50 hour gameplay Sqaure ensured no longer feel so....cheap
2. Can stop random encounters earlier with items. I got that item like 5 hours into the game, which was approximately when I got sick of the battles. I didn't know Diablo had such ability the first time I played ff8
3. More control of your characters at last. In FF8, you have next to no control. It was all about what you junction. Squall gets too strong since you can't ever kick him off your team. In ff10, everyone's sphere grid is too linear (except Kimahri). Finally in X-2, you get to choose your class and what skills to learn.
4. The game was slightly more challenging. I managed to get game overs!!! in FF8 and 10, it was all too easy.
5. Chain attacks are a minor but nice addition.

You got to admit, the game system is better. I found it less tedious. I guess they were trying to bring girls to the FF fanbase with a story like that. That didn't seem to work.

3 out of 12 is a good representation of the game series I think. Considering how a good portion of the fanbase lies there. I only have a PS2 so the only other FF game I might get is ff7.

Personally, with the exception of Tactics, I thought that pretty much all of the FF games after VI sucked. I never brought myself to play VII. It is probably the most hyped FF game ever. I heard so much about the game before and after it came out that I had lost all desire to even play it, even today.

The quality of the stories have gone to the wayside in order to make way for beautiful graphics. A side effect of this is that games have gotten shorter and shorter. Sure, if you do all of the side-quests you could add 10-20 hours of gameplay to the game, but nearly all of the side-quests don't affect the main storyline; they are simply fillers thrown in so that companies can state that the game has "30+ hours of gameplay" on the box. Contrast that to FF VI where most of the side-quests at the end of the game revolved around getting back all of the other characters, quite a few of which added more story to the game. Many of the advances in games today revolve around advances in the game's technology rather than what should be the driving force behind the game: it's story. The Final Fantasy series is no exception to this.

If you want a good FF experience, I suggest playing either IV (II in the US - re-released under it's original title with Chrono Trigger in the FF Chronicles set for ps1), V (released along with VI in the FF Anthologies set for PS1) VI (III in the US). I would also recommend Tactics, which has a rather intriguing story, but that is a different kind of game altogether. Another really good, story driven RPG, though not a FF game, would be Xenogears (also my personally favorite console RPG of all time).

As for random battles, that is something you're simply going to have to deal with. They have been with console RPGs since the days of yore and aren't likely to go away any time soon. The same thing goes with the rather linear gameplay. If you want a good non-linear, random battle-less RPG, you should check out the Elder Scroll series for the computer, the latest of which is Morrowind which has also been released on the Xbox.

No, you are not the only one that feels the Final Fantasy series is over-rated. Like everything else that goes from being a cult classic to being mainstream, it has become over-rated and to an extent even crappy.

FF seems to divide people into 3 groups: those who hate it, those who like the newer games (VII and forward), and those who like the older ones (VI and older). Sure, it's not going to interest some people, just like not all people like FPS, or racing, or sports, or fighting, or simulations. Many of the haters resent all the attention FF gets, but, when a series has been around for so long, and been so popular with large numbers of people, those people want to hear about their favorite game. No one can deny that each FF (yes even X-2) is a grand undertaking, requiring many hours of play, and amazing skill to create. Then, there is the dissention among the FF lovers...the old-schoolers claim that the new games have dumped story/character development/gameplay for improved graphics. I personally disagree with this viewpoint. All the FF stories, love 'em or hate 'em are huge affairs, with twists, turns, and a mosaic of personal and worldshaking issues. Especially I feel that voiced characters (and I didn't mind any of the voices in X or X-2) creates more personalized characters, helping convey emotions that previously had to be illustrated by music or imagery.

FF supporters and detractors also tend to be very vocal, understandable considering the magnatude of the subject of their arguments. The haters and old-school supporters, being the minority, are also more vicious in their debate. The fact that so many newbies have only been exposed to the absolute worst games from their standpoint only fuels their anger. Unfortunate, but that's the way it is.

Now, rumors have been spreading about Square-Enix finally closing out the series, and accusations about S-E milking the series, making it mainstream at the cost of game quality (except graphics), fuelled by all the newcomers drawn in by the impressive visuals. Both issues are possibly true, the second more than the first in my opinion (why would S-E shut down a guaranteed multi-million dollar franchise?). But as an FF supporter I worry about the true decline of the series due to quantity over quality mentality.

all ff sucked but 7

page 1 of 2

Only members can post replies, please register.