Another one of my wallpaper submittion got deleted, thank you for the
notification, but I have to object on this one.
Note: I do not have the image, because I'm posting this through my Mac, but it
something like this
(plus background of course)
1. I know it's a simple one, but can't we have a simple wallpaper once in a
while?
2. Although it looks simple, I did not use any scan or anything, I drew it from
sketch, even outlined in using computer, up to the finish stage. So It does look
simple, but the process is not (unless I use scan and just chuck in the
background, now... that is effortless).
3. IF you think this is not up to PAR, then I would be greatfull if you could
suggest me what do I have to add to this piece so that it's in the best state to
be publish in the main gallery.
4. when you (or any moderator) deleted a submittion, I really hope (and will
appreciate more) if you guys give us the EXACT reason, and not just copy and
paste using the general refusal comment (especially the automated reply)
5.
Quote: It was a low effort
wallpaper
Quote: We only accept wallpapers
where the members make a true effort
now if anyone could suggest me what is the TRUE EFFORT. If sketching it from
scratch is not effort, then what is?
6. Itâs look simple, but the thought behind it is not. I know the
âbunnyâ stamp kind of backround looks just like a last minute
thought, but if anyone CARE to know, it actually gone through some process as
well (design wise).
So it is a pity that only things that looks complicated got accepted. I wonder
if the gallery moderator even âobserveâ the submittion more
closely. Another pity is the rejection itself, canât it be at least be a
bit more personalize. Because the one I submitted is certainly not
Quote: It used screenshots or
unmodified stock photos
, nor
Quote: It featured a poor quality extraction or had many
artifacts on the images
, and certainly this one does not
apply to mine
Quote: It did not
feature an anime-style image
What kind of wallpaper can be submitted then? With lots of grunge background? Or
if I draw it myself, with lots of characters?
Now, I do not looking for a fight with MT moderators, especially MT gallery
moderator. Iâm sure itâs a hard job, and one that is under
appreciated (just like a teacher). I am merely another powerless MT member (who
is somehow always at fault) looking for a enlightment.
I am just annoyed (reason, read above).
Now, any responses, I thank you in advance. And letâs hope this thread
does not get closed down, just because one member voice her
disagreement.
Thank you
Sincerely,
MPhnx/Wynnter/Win.
BotChii wrote at 12-19-2005 ~ 02:38pm
Quote: MPhnx,
The wallpaper you have submitted entitled Bunny Girl was deleted for one or more
or the following reasons:
- It was too simplistic, with poor layout or background
- It was too blurry or overfiltered
- ]It used screenshots or unmodified stock photos
- It featured a poor quality extraction or had many artifacts on the images
- It was a low effort wallpaper
- It was an alternate version of an existing wallpaper. Please only upload one
version of a wallpaper. If you wish to display alternate versions, you may post
an offsite link.
- It did not feature an anime-style image. See this announcement for more
information: http://forum.minitokyo.net/showthread/35992/
to submit quality works for critiques and advice.
For more information, refer to the Policy and the FAQ
For help with making wallpapers, refer to the Art & Design Lounge.
Sincerely,
Minitokyo Staff
This is an automated message and cannot be replied.
Another one of my wallpaper submittion got deleted, thank you for the notification, but I have to object on this one.
Note: I do not have the image, because I'm posting this through my Mac, but it something like this (plus background of course)
1. I know it's a simple one, but can't we have a simple wallpaper once in a while?
2. Although it looks simple, I did not use any scan or anything, I drew it from sketch, even outlined in using computer, up to the finish stage. So It does look simple, but the process is not (unless I use scan and just chuck in the background, now... that is effortless).
3. IF you think this is not up to PAR, then I would be greatfull if you could suggest me what do I have to add to this piece so that it's in the best state to be publish in the main gallery.
4. when you (or any moderator) deleted a submittion, I really hope (and will appreciate more) if you guys give us the EXACT reason, and not just copy and paste using the general refusal comment (especially the automated reply)
5.
now if anyone could suggest me what is the TRUE EFFORT. If sketching it from scratch is not effort, then what is?
6. Itâs look simple, but the thought behind it is not. I know the âbunnyâ stamp kind of backround looks just like a last minute thought, but if anyone CARE to know, it actually gone through some process as well (design wise).
So it is a pity that only things that looks complicated got accepted. I wonder if the gallery moderator even âobserveâ the submittion more closely. Another pity is the rejection itself, canât it be at least be a bit more personalize. Because the one I submitted is certainly not
, nor
, and certainly this one does not apply to mine
What kind of wallpaper can be submitted then? With lots of grunge background? Or if I draw it myself, with lots of characters?
Now, I do not looking for a fight with MT moderators, especially MT gallery moderator. Iâm sure itâs a hard job, and one that is under appreciated (just like a teacher). I am merely another powerless MT member (who is somehow always at fault) looking for a enlightment.
I am just annoyed (reason, read above).
Now, any responses, I thank you in advance. And letâs hope this thread does not get closed down, just because one member voice her disagreement.
Thank you
Sincerely,
MPhnx/Wynnter/Win.
BotChii wrote at 12-19-2005 ~ 02:38pm
PS: if I put this in the wrong subforum, please kindly move it to the proper subforum. Thank you.
I know how u feel, but please refer and take your complaints here:
http://forum.minitokyo.net/thread/38205/complaints-deleted-images-warnings-bans/
official sticky thread for complaints, there is no need for another thread to be made.
right. thank you for your direction. *Quickly copy and paste to the right place.
Yeah, this this is just what's happening to me all the time!
Whenever l submitt a wallpaper, it get deleted 3-6 days later.WHAT'S GOING ON!
As noted, please file all deletion complaints in the official deletion complaint thread.