Well Al and Ed made their decision and said that they will stay in the Other
World! Isn't it a painful ending for Winry ? Is really Ed gonna leave Winry
alone ? I hope they will make a special episode so we can see the (truly) END
!
I want to ask you guys what do you think about its End? Do you believe they
really want to live in the other world (without Alchemy) & leave poor Winry
alone ? What is your opinion ?
Have you read the manga, because apparently the ending of the anime is different
to it.
As for Winry being left behind, yeah it is sad, but then I suppose if she did
come with them it would have been too much of a happy ending. I don't really see
Ed and Winry together though as a couple, I mean I can see it, but I don't think
she is just there as a love, she's like a really close childhood
friend.
I tell you though, I would have been DEVESTATED if Ed went back all by himself
and Al didn't come. Lol at the start of the movie when they first open the gate
I was like yelling at Al to go through the gate and wasn't very happy that Rose
decided to hold him back :P
I love the brothers relationship.(L)
As for truely the end - there never really is truely an end, and all things
consider I think things worked out quite well.
AyuTateishi, I'd love to tell you, but I haven't read the end either, but I
shall be headed to a comic store as soon as I can to find out:P
As for Noa, I think she is pretty, in her own way, like Winry is a bit of a
cliche ish anime character, but I think she is a better character than Noa, Noa
is a bit to much concerned with herself - yes I know she was ridiculed and all
that, but she is not the girl I picture with Ed, or Al.
AyuTateishi , have you seen the movie - I'm guessing not :P it's quite good, it
does explain the end of the series - you should see it
There is definitely no suggestion between Al are Noa in the movie however there
is kind of a 'friendship' between Ed and Noa, but nothing to suggest they are to
be a couple. Noa could possibly be fascinated with Ed because of the world he
comes from, but Ed didn't show interest in her as far as I could tell
Thanks for the info. I'm planning on getting the movie this weekend but the
suspense is killing me. I really wanted to know what are the events. Well...
thanks a lot.
i like the ending of the movie; ed and al get to stay together. i really believe
when al said that as long as they are together,they will find a way.it is sad
that winry was left behind but hey,someday ed and al will come back.i believe
so^_^ the great thing abt this series is how they potray the strength of human
relationship; brotherhood,friendships,companionships..surely it won't be easy
for ed and al to find their way back,but they will!they surely will!
I do and I don't - it's just normally sequels suck - it's like the producers
thought 'Well everyone loved the 1st, let's quickly make a second, no matter how
crap it is because it doesn't matter they will go see it anyway.'
I know it's not always like that, but I'd rather them not produce a second movie
at all if it's going to be just a cheap version of it.
It's hard for them to do a sequel to it too I reckon - not giving too many
spoilers AyuTateishi . It would
have to be done quite artfully. For one thing, a key factor of the Full Metal
Alchemist series doesn't exist in the world Ed is in...
When I first found that out, I was devistated. Just thinking they are in this
other world without Winry or anyone else they've known for so long is just sad.
I don't think that he picked Winry over Noa - to me there isn't even a
suggestion that he likes her. Winry is sooo much better for Ed anyway than Noa
^_^
Have you seen the movie Kawaiiakanbo? *Mild spoiler* Ed not so much wanted to go
back but he didn't really have a choice - to protect the world that he grew up
in with all the people he loves, he had to return so he could destroy the other
side of the gate
I think they left any opening for a 2nd movie...Al got his memories back I
believe due to him traveling through the gate, so he remembers the guy from the
opening sequence of the 1st movie...the one with the bomb. I think they need to
remove the last vestage of their world from this world before they are able to
go back. So I think they could make a 2nd interesting movie...and end it with
them going home. I hope to see something like that.
Yes, I do believe that they will have something else to add to this series. Ed
has already pointed out one task they have to achieve and shouldn't we be
allowed to see that?
There is no clear conclusion to what happened to Roy and the other members of
the military. Why the heck is Armstrong at the Rockbell household and why
doesn't Winry get a break for a change? Bar the pictures she is the last person
we see and to me that seems significant.
Whether it will be a 2nd movie or another (short series) I could not guess but
they have certainly left it open enough. Perhaps they are waiting for the
reaction of the audience.
As for the manga, thats just keeps on coming anyway!
I havent read the manga but i have seen the movie ! I believe that they do left
an opening for a second movie! I think at the very end they will change their
minds and they won't destroy the Gate... So they will return back to their real
world !
But if Roy has destroyed it on the other side then they cannot get back through.
Plus I believe they did destry it as that was the first thing he was to do once
he had returned to our world.
The movie was very interesting, yet the ending made me feel somewhat emppty due
to the fact that winry was left behind and "alone" if you knoe what I
mean. As for something like ed or al getting with Noa, I don't knoe but we can
all imagine things up haha jk. I would definetly like to knoe the ending of the
manga. I doubt a second movie will come or anything tho but who knoes...
i bought the imported movie on discountanime......but the subbing is like
sooooooo off.......and the movie was somewhat like blah.......all slapped
together quickly.
Well Al and Ed made their decision and said that they will stay in the Other World! Isn't it a painful ending for Winry ? Is really Ed gonna leave Winry alone ? I hope they will make a special episode so we can see the (truly) END !
? What is your opinion ? 
I want to ask you guys what do you think about its End? Do you believe they really want to live in the other world (without Alchemy) & leave poor Winry alone
I want them to go back to Winry...
Have you read the manga, because apparently the ending of the anime is different to it.
As for Winry being left behind, yeah it is sad, but then I suppose if she did come with them it would have been too much of a happy ending. I don't really see Ed and Winry together though as a couple, I mean I can see it, but I don't think she is just there as a love, she's like a really close childhood friend.
I tell you though, I would have been DEVESTATED if Ed went back all by himself and Al didn't come. Lol at the start of the movie when they first open the gate I was like yelling at Al to go through the gate and wasn't very happy that Rose decided to hold him back :P
I love the brothers relationship.(L)
As for truely the end - there never really is truely an end, and all things consider I think things worked out quite well.
Well to tell the truth i prefer that he stayed to the other world because i think Noa is Far more cuter than Winry
May I ask... what is the ending of the manga? I haven't read it... Please!
AyuTateishi, I'd love to tell you, but I haven't read the end either, but I shall be headed to a comic store as soon as I can to find out:P
As for Noa, I think she is pretty, in her own way, like Winry is a bit of a cliche ish anime character, but I think she is a better character than Noa, Noa is a bit to much concerned with herself - yes I know she was ridiculed and all that, but she is not the girl I picture with Ed, or Al.
Does the movie hint some relationship between Ed and Noa or Al and Noe. I mean does anyone like the other? I'm just curious.
AyuTateishi , have you seen the movie - I'm guessing not :P it's quite good, it does explain the end of the series - you should see it
There is definitely no suggestion between Al are Noa in the movie however there is kind of a 'friendship' between Ed and Noa, but nothing to suggest they are to be a couple. Noa could possibly be fascinated with Ed because of the world he comes from, but Ed didn't show interest in her as far as I could tell
Thanks for the info. I'm planning on getting the movie this weekend but the suspense is killing me. I really wanted to know what are the events. Well... thanks a lot.
Where are you getting the movie from, I sooo want it!
Let me know what you think of it once you see okay!
Ok. I'm planning on looking for it in different stores this weekend. If ever I don't find any, I think I would just download it.
i like the ending of the movie; ed and al get to stay together. i really believe when al said that as long as they are together,they will find a way.it is sad that winry was left behind but hey,someday ed and al will come back.i believe so^_^ the great thing abt this series is how they potray the strength of human relationship; brotherhood,friendships,companionships..surely it won't be easy for ed and al to find their way back,but they will!they surely will!
I hope there's another movie.
I do and I don't - it's just normally sequels suck - it's like the producers thought 'Well everyone loved the 1st, let's quickly make a second, no matter how crap it is because it doesn't matter they will go see it anyway.'
I know it's not always like that, but I'd rather them not produce a second movie at all if it's going to be just a cheap version of it.
It's hard for them to do a sequel to it too I reckon - not giving too many spoilers AyuTateishi
. It would
have to be done quite artfully. For one thing, a key factor of the Full Metal
Alchemist series doesn't exist in the world Ed is in...
When I first found that out, I was devistated. Just thinking they are in this other world without Winry or anyone else they've known for so long is just sad.
Yeah. That's why I was hoping for a second movie. It would be nice if they found a way to be together again with Winry and the others.
Can't believe Ed picked Noa over Winry... I mean he hardly knows her...
Why won't Ed stay in his original world? Doesn't he miss his Alchemy skills as seen during hte movie?
I don't think that he picked Winry over Noa - to me there isn't even a suggestion that he likes her. Winry is sooo much better for Ed anyway than Noa ^_^
Have you seen the movie Kawaiiakanbo? *Mild spoiler* Ed not so much wanted to go back but he didn't really have a choice - to protect the world that he grew up in with all the people he loves, he had to return so he could destroy the other side of the gate
I think they left any opening for a 2nd movie...Al got his memories back I believe due to him traveling through the gate, so he remembers the guy from the opening sequence of the 1st movie...the one with the bomb. I think they need to remove the last vestage of their world from this world before they are able to go back. So I think they could make a 2nd interesting movie...and end it with them going home. I hope to see something like that.
Yes, I do believe that they will have something else to add to this series. Ed has already pointed out one task they have to achieve and shouldn't we be allowed to see that?
There is no clear conclusion to what happened to Roy and the other members of the military. Why the heck is Armstrong at the Rockbell household and why doesn't Winry get a break for a change? Bar the pictures she is the last person we see and to me that seems significant.
Whether it will be a 2nd movie or another (short series) I could not guess but they have certainly left it open enough. Perhaps they are waiting for the reaction of the audience.
As for the manga, thats just keeps on coming anyway!
I havent read the manga but i have seen the movie ! I believe that they do left an opening for a second movie! I think at the very end they will change their minds and they won't destroy the Gate... So they will return back to their real world !
But if Roy has destroyed it on the other side then they cannot get back through. Plus I believe they did destry it as that was the first thing he was to do once he had returned to our world.
The movie was very interesting, yet the ending made me feel somewhat emppty due to the fact that winry was left behind and "alone" if you knoe what I mean. As for something like ed or al getting with Noa, I don't knoe but we can all imagine things up haha jk. I would definetly like to knoe the ending of the manga. I doubt a second movie will come or anything tho but who knoes...
i bought the imported movie on discountanime......but the subbing is like sooooooo off.......and the movie was somewhat like blah.......all slapped together quickly.