Im Going to go with Noir.......I haven't seen Madlax yet but From what I hear it aint as good as Noir and I didnt like .Hack at all...So Noir is my pick whats yours?

I've never watched Noir. I found Madlax dragging in places, but was a good show overall, even though it left me a little confused. I really liked the music from .hack, and that's about it. I don't really have a favourite, after all.

Im a noir fan myself the art is just gorgeous although I did like .hacks soundtrack a little bit more (fake wings or salva nos...so hard to choose!)

Madlax forever! I watched Madlax and really loved it(especially the songs and Madlax of course ) and also tried Noir but couldn't continoue after the first 4 eps. I don't know it's just probably me but I didn't feel that I want to watch the next episode and know what's gonna happen like with any other anime I watched so far. Altough I think I'm gonna give it a second shot when I have a little time again cause my friend told me that the first 4 or 5 eps are not so great and you just have to get over them.

I enjoyed Noir very much. My friends were telling me that it would probably be boring to me, but I just kept watching episode after episode.

i like .hack

noir was okay and has one of my fav OSTs, but whenever .hack made a MMO reference i smiled.