Login

Login

Need to register? Lost password?

Options

Advertisements

Advertisements

 

Is Light bad or good?

In-depth Discussions

Minitokyo » Forum » Anime & Manga Fora » In-depth Discussions  Is Light bad or good?

page 1 of 1

I don't know if Light is bad or good.....I mean he has good intentions but have bad and unforgivable actions -_-. I don't know if he's really a good boy or not X-O. what do u think about Light?

hmm... I think Light-kun is a good bad a$$...! :D
or bad good lad? heh! either of them suit him though...

Obviously..... he's trying to reform the cursed world full of evil and the walking dead

His intentions are good but his way of doing it is bad...

Nuff said!

he's bad. he's greedy for death. other people's death. and he wants to kill my boyfriend, ( L Lawliet). that makes him really bad. and he thinks of himself as a god. disgusting.

He maybe wanted to do sth good,to make the world clean,he thought he personified the justice,but he was too extreme

he's drunk with power...power to be God.
just wanting to be like him is bad enough
Light killing people to get rid of evil in the world
and also thinking that he's going to be the new God is just
disgusting


Light has a good and-- what can I say? "pure" mind at first. It was the Death Note that made him into something.... pure evil and extremely power hungry... His purpose, as he himself puts it, wants to bring justice to this world. What he's just doing is the same with what the criminal he punishes was in jail for. Murder, deceit and the likes... Damn, I hate his character because of this... :(

of course he's a bad person! He kills people!

Light is the "light". The "light" is good as long as it dosen't burn you. The same situation is with Light (Kira) it's the good guy till you do something bad and he kills you. I think Light is good.

Depending on which point of view you see it from.
In his own opinion, Light is good, because he is doing what no one else is. He thinks he can change the world in a positive way, and he doesn't mind the way he chooses to do so.
From another person's point of view, Light can be considered bad, because taking another one's life is a crime, regardless of what that person has done to you. Unless that person is convicted and sentenced to death, of course.
I can't really say if he's good or bad, it depends on the event that's happening during the question. Because Light's actions can't be judged in general, each one can be characterized in its own way.

Let's just say that if Light was a Dungeons and Dragons character he would be a "lawful evil" type. His cause is noble but the means are cruel.

he wouldnt be a lawful evil person! he would be Chaotic Neutral lol

Well the original Light was good. But after L's death i dont know either. Aww, even he`s evil im on his side. :D

its more lik "does the end justify the means"...

but i mean whether u think of him as evil or not, in the anime (not the manga unfortunately.. hes disgusting in the ending of the manga)
anywayz, in the anime, don't u sympathize with him!? i mean its SOOO sad!

n yea i agree.. the death note corrupts u
still light's just too good-looking to b completely evil XD (so shallow ><)

he's evil

Evil is subjective! Light wants to rid the world of injustice, he obtains the power and has the intellect to outwit even "L" he is a god in the world he lives in. To be able to manipulate and mold, discard of whoever you want, this is power.

Please do not bump old threads.

page 1 of 1

Only members can post replies, please register.